|
|
|
|
|
Windsor Town Council
Council Chambers – Town Hall
August 2, 2004
Approved Minutes
Mayor Trinks called the regular meeting to order at
7:32 p.m.
- Roll Call – Present: Mayor Trinks, Deputy
Mayor Curtis, Councilor Broxterman, Councilor
Ellingwood, Councilor Dean, Councilor Jepsen,
Councilor Mulligan, Councilor Simon and Councilor
Walker
- Prayer – Councilor Jepsen
- Pledge of Allegiance – Councilor Jepsen
- Proclamations/Awards
- Proclamation Honoring the Poquonock Fire
Company’s 75th Anniversary
Councilor Simon read the proclamation honoring
the Poquonock Fire Company’s 75th
Anniversary. Gary Christensen accepted the
proclamation. The members of the Poquonock Fire
Company invite the community to share their 75th
anniversary celebration by attending an Open House
from 10:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. scheduled for Saturday,
August 21, 2004
- Public Communications and Petitions
Mr. Franz Krot, 281 Carriage Way, addressed the
Council. His cost of living adjustment rose 1-½
percent, but his real estate bill increased by 28%. He
questioned if the budget would have passed if the
public were told their property taxes would increase
28% or the rumored 15%. He also questioned if the
public was misled. He asked if we can believe that a
six million dollar library expansion would cost
taxpayers only a few dollars a year. Please spare us
the fuzzy math and tell us the truth.
Mr. James Babb, 35 Crystal Lane, on behalf of the
Caribbean Showcase Committee, thanked the Council and
town for letting them have the showcase. There are
several cultures represented in Windsor. He believes
that if you know the culture of others, you will have
a happier life. He noted that there were no
disturbances that required police intervention. He
urged residents to volunteer in town. He hopes not to
see a Caribbean Showcase but a Windsor Showcase
representing all of the cultures in Windsor in the
future.
Ms. Mickey Mattei, 108 Gary Lynn Lane, alerted the
Council regarding a zoning issue that will be coming
up tomorrow. She invited the Town of Windsor to attend
the Roberta Flack concert at SummerWind this weekend.
Mr. Edward Borowski, 221 Castlewood Drive, is
disappointed in the 20% increase on his tax bill. He
quoted the budget deliberations as stating a 4%
increase in taxes. He wanted to know if the tax
increase is proportionate to all the residents in
Windsor.
Ms. Lynne Gillette, 11 Aster Place, read in the
Windsor Journal that the position of Town Manager was
not going to be open to applicants. She thinks that it
would be beneficial to the town and to Mr. Souza if
others could apply for the position. She liked the
process that was taken when the Superintendent of
Schools was selected and how it was open to the
public. She encouraged the Council to do the same with
the Town Manager’s position. She doesn’t think a
national search needs to be done, but a regional
search would suffice. We want to see this community
working together. Recently, the pond at Walden Woods
is a mess, it has green slime, and it needs to be
addressed. She stated that a good portion of money had
to be spent fighting the citizens in this town. The
citizens of Walden Woods had to spend $200,000 in
three and a half years to fight not to have apartments
in Walden Woods. She was delighted when Mr. Wayne
Radke, Public Works Department, came to Walden Woods
with his associate. It was nice having him spend some
time there.
Mr. Fenton Lewis, 37 Ludlow Road, addressed the
Council regarding the tax increase. He is a new
homeowner. His taxes increased $1,500. He doesn’t mind
paying his share, but he feels that it was a
misrepresentation. It also seems that certain people
are paying more and some are paying less of a fair
share.
Mr. Richard Rutkowski, 295 Kings Landing, spoke to
the Council. He noted real estate changes and examples
of significant decreases in commercial and industrial
taxes. The average reduction is 12.3%. He displayed a
chart of the distribution of the grand list including
residential, commercial and industrial in 2002 and
2003. Resident owners have had enough in this town.
The town budget in 2003 vs. 2004 property taxes for
$62 million and all other revenue is $15 million for a
total of $77 million. In 2004, it was $64-65 million
for property taxes and $16 million for other for a
total of $80 million. That is an increase of $3.3
million or 4.4% increase in spending. The burden of
taxation must shift from the residential base to the
commercial and industrial base. This must stop or we
will start to see an exit of the residents in Windsor,
especially of the senior citizens who live on a fixed
income. We need to reverse that trend.
Ms. Laura Rose spoke of the tax increase of 22.6%
for the Winter Woods area. Only 6% of residents
received an increase of 4%. She is speaking on behalf
of single mothers, homeowners, and families who are
putting their children through college. She was
embarrassed when her mortgage company called her and
thought there was an error in her tax increase and she
had to tell them it was not an error.
Mr. Edward Thomas, 192 Capen Street, is concerned
about the recent budget increase. He owns a house, a
business and a commercial building in town. After the
referendum was approved, on his street the increase
was anywhere from 4-24%. Part of this was due to
revaluation. Most people in this town have no clue how
the budget process works and actually expect to pay an
increase every year, as long as it is a reasonable
increase. They are looking for someone to lead this
town who has no ties to the previous administration.
Mr. William Generous, 30 Karen Circle, distributed
a sheet describing the recent tax increase
misrepresentation in both pictures and words.
Essentially, town staff used an incorrect and
inappropriate "house" value prior to revaluation when
deriving the representative residential real estate
tax increase. This resulted in part of the real estate
median "house" appreciation not being disclosed. He
believes that the prior median "house" value of
$138,000 used to derive the tax increase was incorrect
and is really closer to $128,000. Another result was
that an additional 8% of residential real estate tax
increase was not publicly disclosed as part of the
budget referendum materials. He attempted to file a
written ethics complaint at the July 12th,
2004 Town of Windsor Board of Ethics meeting. He was
informed that a resident cannot file the complaint
directly but that it had to be referred by the Town
Manager or a Town Council member at a regularly
scheduled Town Council meeting. He is hoping his
ethics complaint will be referred tonight. His primary
complaint is against Mr. Leon Churchill, Former Town
Manager; Mr. Peter Souza, Acting Town Manager; and Mr.
Steve Kosofsky, Town Assessor. The complaint focuses
on the misrepresentation of the residential real
estate tax increase that may have possibly been
willful. This is more about ethics and government
accountability. It is about the town staff possibly
taking advantage of a trusting and time strapped
public that in large mass was not engaged in the
budget referendum. Councilor Simon is the only Town
Council member that publicly stated that he believed
there was a misrepresentation.
Mr. Sam Hinckley, 209 Palisado Avenue, spoke about
the comments made in the public hearing earlier this
evening about the possible sale of the East Street
property. He is the President of the First School
Society, who owns and manages two cemeteries in
Windsor. It is their only activity and will remain the
only activity they are ever involved in.
Ms. Jennifer O’Neill, 124 Winterwood, said that she
is new to Windsor as of last year. One of the reasons
they chose to live in Windsor was the diversity in
town. They also liked the median home values that they
could afford. They were shocked to see a 25% tax
increase on their taxes this year. It is too much for
them to bear. She is disappointed that their 25% tax
increase is in effect while the commercial and
industrial taxes went down. They could be forced to
look tat another town that doesn’t have such high tax
increases.
Mr. Milton Walsh, 31 Joshua Hill, spoke to the
Council regarding the large tax increase. Everyone
took at face value the information provided in the
budget sessions. There are lots of individuals in town
who are on fixed incomes. Clearly, citizenship needs
to get more involved in this process. Individuals need
to be held accountable for this miscalculation. There
are other towns that are attractive for residents to
move to. The members of this Council took advantage of
the apathy of residents in the town. It is important
to examine each and every member of the Council and
their voting history.
Ms. Wanda Colon-Ayala, 224 Castlewood Drive, has
lived in Windsor almost nine years. She chose Windsor
because of her children and the neighborhoods. Her
children would like to stay in Windsor. With this
increase in taxes, as a single parent and with a child
about to attend college, she has to carefully
determine if she can afford to stay in Windsor.
Mr. Sylvester Wynter, 74 Joshua Hill, spoke about
his 33.8% tax increase. He is very upset and would
like to know why it went up that much.
Mr. George Yeramian, 739 Prospect Hill Road,
discussed the minutes of the last meeting in July. The
minutes from the last meeting left off his suggestion
of rerouting the dump road, but he said that it should
follow with "through the woods to the dump road gate".
He requested that the minutes be changed.
- Report of Appointed Boards and Commissions
- Board of Education
Ms. Jane Garibay, Board of Education, reported to
the Council. The first day of school is August 31,
2004. They hired Robin G. Sorensen as Assistant
Superintendent and Patricia Staszko-Kozik as
Director of Pupil and Special Education Services.
A couple of teaching positions are still open,
but hiring for the most part is completed. There are
40 new teachers. Ellsworth has a new Vice Principal,
Ms. Eileen Andrews. JFK tile is complete and
carpeting will be done soon. The Veteran Memorial
Monument was installed at Poquonock School.
Councilor Broxterman asked if the Board would
meet this month. Ms. Garibay responded that the
school board would not meet formally this month.
- Public Building Commission
Mr. Joseph Novak, Chair, reported to the Council.
WHS – is essentially complete. Rooftop screening
installation is scheduled to arrive soon and will be
complete by the time school starts.
Goslee Pool – Aluminum awnings have been installed
and the project will be closed out in the near future.
L.P. Wilson Roof – most materials have been delivered
and work will begin this week.
Library Expansion Project – They are looking at
temporary sites. The offices may remain in use. The cost
estimate was higher than anticipated, but only 5% higher
than anticipated and they feel they can work around it.
L.P. Wilson/Sage Park floors – they are on schedule
and will be ready for the start of school.
JFK Floor Tile Abatement – on schedule.
Councilor Broxterman asked if and when we determine
the temporary site, are we projecting that the library
will be using that space or will it be storage. Mr.
Novak said that it is for public use with parking
spaces.
Moved by Councilor Jepsen, seconded by Councilor
Broxterman to take a two-minute recess.
Motion Passed 9-0-0
- Town Manager’s Report
Still time to enter "Windsor Bridge-Builders Awards
"Public Invited to Submit Nominations Now
This week is the deadline to submit a nomination
for the "Windsor Bridge-Builders Awards" sponsored by
the Town of Windsor Human Relations Commission and
Citizens for a United Windsor. Anyone, of any age, may
fill out an official nomination form for the 10th
annual awards program.
The Windsor Bridge-Builders Awards showcases true
community role models in human relations. This can
include students who have worked toward greater
understanding of others in their school or
neighborhood.
Citizens for a United Windsor, a grass-roots
organization, works to foster greater trust,
understanding, and solidarity across the full
spectrum of Windsor's racial, ethnic, and religious
diversity.
Three individuals, organizations, or businesses
will be honored as Windsor Bridge-Builders at a
ceremony and reception to be held on Thursday, Sept.
30, 2004 at the main branch of the Windsor Public
Library. The event will be open to the community.
Official nomination forms for the Windsor
Bridge-Builders Awards are available at the Town
Clerk's office in Town Hall, at the Main branch and
the Wilson branches of the Windsor Public Library, and
at L P. Wilson Community Center, outside of the
Recreation Department.
For more information about this awards program,
call Bill Warner-Prouty at 688-7718, Nellie Holmes
Mason at 728-0769, or Len Swade at 688-4351.
Efforts of Volunteers Recognized as Valuable
Resource
In 2003, 157 individuals volunteered at the Windsor
Senior Center for a total of 5,120 hours. This is an
increase of approximately 1,400 hours from past years.
Delivering meals to homebound residents and working in
the Senior Center office are two of the more popular
volunteer opportunities, but there is a wide variety
of jobs such as helping with the production of the
newsletter, helping at the flu clinic and health fair
and many others.
A member of the senior center staff recently
attended a Volunteer Workshop, and was advised that a
volunteer's time is worth $17.05 per hour. Using that
rate, the 2003 volunteer hours represent a savings to
the town in the amount of $87,306.23.
Every year a Volunteer Luncheon is held to express
our appreciation and to say thank you to the
volunteers, and special recognitions are noted in the
monthly Senior Newsletter.
Road Repairs This Week
Today, the town began using a new process called
MulchSEAL to crack seal portions of River Street
(between Hayden Station Road and Kennedy Road) and Day
Hill Road (between Baker Hollow Road and Poquonock
Avenue). Work will be performed by the town’s
contractor, Marino Brothers of New England, Inc. from
Middletown, CT, and will continue this week, from 7:30
AM to 3:30 PM ending this Friday, August 6th.
MulchSEAL is a process that involves applying
liquid asphalt in the cracks of the roadway and
covering the area with a lightweight cover material.
The MulchSEAL method of crack filling is an
improvement over other crack filling methods. It is
longer lasting on the pavement, especially on streets
with heavier traffic. The liquid asphalt takes
approximately 48 hours to set, so some dust and loose
material will occur during that time. Motorists are
asked to exercise caution driving through the effected
area. There will be minor delays during the
application process and vehicular traffic will be
limited to one lane in those areas. It may be
desirable to plan an alternate route, if possible.
For more information, contact Public Works at
285-1855.
Economic Development Update
On occasion in the past, we have taken the
opportunity to highlight specific economic development
projects. This evening, I would like to provide a
broader picture of economic development activity since
October 1999.
As a whole, Windsor has done well in terms of
economic development and grand list growth. Since
October 1999, 1.6 million square feet of
non-residential building has taken place. This
includes brand new structures and building additions.
It does not include significant reinvestment in
buildings such as Terry Steam on Lamberton Road and
ADVO’s corporate campus off of Bloomfield Ave. Also,
the TPZ has approved an additional 615,000 square feet
of new buildings which have yet to be constructed.
The 1.6 million square feet of construction
translates into over $89 million of grand list growth.
This value is for real estate only and does not take
into account personal property. Furthermore, using a
conservative formula for the 615,000 square feet of
approved yet unbuilt space, there is the potential to
generate an additional $30 million in grand list
value.
The value of the real estate development as of the
October 2003 Grand List translates into approximately
$1.8 million in tax revenue for FY 2005. This equals
8/10ths of a mill. Therefore, all else being equal,
without the past 4 years of economic development
activity, the FY 2005 mill rate would have been 29.63
vs. 28.83. For a home valued at $200,000 this economic
growth translates into a reduced tax burden of $112.
I would like to stress that these numbers include
only real estate values and do not include personal
property. For example, the Marriott Hotel and
Conference Center pays $445,000 in real estate taxes
along with an additional $84,000 in personal property
taxes. In a number of cases involving commercial or
industrial properties, the personal property and
machinery can generate as much or more in revenue than
the real estate.
Windsor stills maintains a fairly well balanced
economic base. Thirty percent of our value is
non-residential. This is better than many communities
in the Hartford region as well as statewide.
Staff is committed to continuing our aggressive
economic development efforts while also focussing on
redevelopment of key sites and small business
retention and assistance.
- Communication from Council Members
Councilor Broxterman – In 1988 and 1989, the median
value home went from $65,000 to $175,000. The market
dictates this, not the Council. It ebbs and flows and
never comes at a good time. He explained the budget
highlights of those years. There was a layoff of 49
teachers and there were no after school programs. There
were cuts in services, like leaf collection. In 1989 his
house cost $242,000 and it’s value decreased to
$175,000, but he still paid on the $242,000. The last
time he refinanced it was valued at $260,000. The
Council doesn’t control, doesn’t impact or have direct
effect on commercial, industrial or residential values.
The wildcard here is the depreciation of commercial and
industrial and the appreciation of residential
properties. The Hartford Courant reported that most
towns in Connecticut use Median Value. Is it right? No,
but that is what they use. Spending was 3.8% - 3.9% more
than last year.
Councilor Dean – was happy to see all of the
residents turn out this evening.
Councilor Ellingwood – thanked everyone who came out
this evening. The whole point of this discussion is to
understand what we know, what we needed to know and how
not to let this happen again.
Councilor Jepsen – thanked everyone for coming out
tonight. He understands the reval process, but 5.8%
became 15%. Councilor Jepsen said that he will submit
Mr. Generous’ complaint to the Ethics Committee.
Councilor Simon – thanked all for coming out tonight.
They will be moving up the item in the meeting tonight
so that all may hear the discussion. The solution at the
time of the 1989 increase was to phase in the increase
over five years. It was a difficult time for the town.
In 1999, most homeowners benefited from a shift in the
increase for commercial and industrial taxes. The reason
it is shifting back again is that homeowner property
values have increased at a faster rate than commercial
or industrial. He doesn’t see a good solution here.
People have a right to be angry and he is hoping that
some of these issues will be clarified later this
evening.
Councilor Mulligan – thanked all for coming out.
Councilor Walker – thanked the teaching staff of CCSU,
the Windsor Police Department, and all that supported
the Caribbean Showcase. Windsor has seen a dramatic
increase in real estate values. While there has been a
shift to residential taxes, we must get more commercial
development on Day Hill Road. We have lost bids to some
companies because we have an antiquated approach. It was
later discovered that we have to do what the other towns
are doing by offering incentives to bring more
commercial development. He noted the tax decrease by the
commercial entities and he requested further
information. Windsor needs to go back to building
requirements. Maybe it’s time to take a dramatic
approach, for example, increasing the lot sizes. Instead
of putting up $200,000 homes, how about benchmarking
higher at $400,000 to attract CEO’s who are moving to
West Hartford. We also need to address the citizen
complaints. Maybe we could make payments twice per year.
Deputy Mayor Curtis – the residents have legitimate
concerns. Some got involved after the fact, just like he
did 14 years ago. He hopes that some of the residents
that came out tonight will stay involved. He said that
we have to make sure that something like this never
happens again. The annual revaluation will not result in
this type of increase, it will keep the burden
relatively stable. There was no attempt to mislead
anyone. He congratulated those who put on the Caribbean
Showcase.
Mayor Trinks – Alexander Scott, who developed Alex’s
Lemonade Stand and raised $700,000 all across the
country, who was also diagnosed at the age of one with
cancer, has passed away. She made a pledge to raise a
million dollars before she died and hopefully this
effort and momentum will continue.
- Reports of Standing Committees
- Finance Committee - None.
- Town Improvements Committee – None.
- Health and Safety – None.
- Special Projects – None.
- Joint Board of Education and Town Council
Committee – None.
- Personnel Committee – None.
- Ordinances
- Approve an ordinance regarding the sale of
property on East Street
Moved by Councilor Jepsen, seconded by Councilor
Broxterman that an ordinance entitled, "THE SALE OF EAST
STREET PROPERTY IN THE AMOUNT OF $130,000.00" be
approved.
The proposed transaction is for the sale of 9.73
acres in the amount of $130,000. The intended use is for
cemetery purposes. The town is required to remove any
public works construction material that is remaining on
the parcel and to complete environmental assessments as
needed. The town will retain public access from the
river’s edge to the top of the slope along with access
from the public road.
The Town Planning & Zoning Commission approved this
transaction via a CGS §8-24 and its proposed use at its
February 10, 2004 meeting.
Councilor Ellingwood asked Acting Town Manager Souza
to discuss the value of the land. Acting Town Manager
Souza said that the development of this parcel is
limited, 50% of the parcel is affected by steep slopes
and wetlands and is in the 100-year flood plan of the
Farmington River. Even though it is nine acres, half is
impacted by development potential. Two lots of fair
market value are estimated to be $180,000 from the Town
Assessor.
Councilor Walker asked if there is anything in the
documentation that places the restriction of the land
being used solely for cemetery use. Acting Town Manager
Souza said if the Council wishes, the staff can add that
requirement.
Councilor Broxterman asked if the First School
Society does any business other than cemeteries. Acting
Town Manager Souza responded that is the only business
they are in.
Motion Passed 9-0-0
- Unfinished Business
None.
- New Business
- Set a Special Town Meeting for September 7, 2004
at 7:15 p.m. (prevailing time) for an ordinance
regarding the sale of property on East Street
Moved by Councilor Jepsen, seconded by Councilor
Broxterman that a Special Town Meeting be set for
September 7, 2004 at 7:15 p.m. (prevailing time) in the
Council Chambers of the Windsor Town Hall, to approve or
disapprove an ordinance entitled "THE SALE OF EAST
STREET PROPERTY IN THE AMOUNT OF $130,000.00", which the
Town Council has recommended its approval and be it
further resolved that the Town Clerk is authorized and
directed to post and publish notice of said Special Town
Meeting.
Motion Passed 9-0-0
Moved by Councilor Simon, seconded by Councilor
Jepsen to move Item 12. G. to this point in the agenda.
Motion Passed 9-0-0
G. Review and discussion of FY 2005 budget
information
Acting Town Manager Souza explained that the FY 2005
Budget expenditures increased $3.3 million or 4.3% over
the FY 2004 Budget.
Of the $3.3 million, the major drivers included:
- BOE 1.9 million
- General Government 900,000
- MDC Sewer 236,000
- Debt Service 257,000
The Town Council and management have taken a number
of actions to mitigate expenditure increases. Such
actions include:
- Refinancing of outstanding debt ($120,000)
- Lower cost for recycling ($40,000)
- Lower liability and workers comp insurance
($120,000)
- Reduced transfer to Pension Plan due to higher
than expected investment performance ($178,000)
- Hired cost containment consultant resulting in a
reduction of approximately $220,000 in expenditures
The Town Council reduced the Town Manager’s proposed
budget by nearly $1.5 million or 1.8%
Acting Town Manager Souza then began to explain how
property revaluation impacted the FY 2005 budget. He
stated the mission or goal of revaluation is to remove
inequities in property assessments.
Revaluation caused the tax burden to shift from
business properties to residential real estate. Primary
factors causing this shift were:
- Residential values appreciated at a higher rate
than business properties
- Personal Property, namely vehicles, lost value
- New growth was 1%, which was relatively low for
Windsor compared to the past 4 or 5 years
In 2002 Residential Assessments totaled 67% and
Non-Residential Assessments equaled 33%.
In 2003 Residential Assessments equaled 70% and
Non-Residential Assessments were 30%.
Residential property values on average increased 29%
and Commercial/Industrial property values on average
increased 20%.
Similar to past years, including the1989 and 1999
revaluations, staff continued the practice of using the
median value home as our comparison point or benchmark.
The 5.8% increase was the tax impact to the median
valued home in 2002 ($138,000, based on sale price) to
the median valued home in 2003 after revaluation
($170,000). This demonstrated the impact on the median
valued home from one year to the next, not the median
tax increase.
This benchmark is used by a range of cities and
towns, along with other public and private agencies. It
is not a perfect indicator of individual tax impact. It
solely shows the impact on the median valued home.
Individual home values increased over a wide range –
therefore individual tax impact varied accordingly. The
average dollar impact was $459, or just below 15%.
Acting Town Manager Souza suggested that the Town
Council and staff continue this discussion in terms of
the best method of how to explain and communicate future
budget impacts. Suggested options may be:
- Developing on the town’s website a Tax Impact
Calculator
- Presenting the residential tax impact in $25,000
increments starting with a $100,000 home through a home valued at $350,000
Both of these options would allow individual property
owners the ability to determine the tax impact of their
property.
Councilor Ellingwood asked if there is statistically,
any value to that number on the median house and asked
when did we realize that it was a mistake. Acting Town
Manager Souza responded that we stayed with the $138,000
as the median and that was obviously in error. Mr. Steve
Kosofsky, Town Assessor, replied that in 2002, it was
67% residential and 33% non-residential. It was his
estimate that it would increase to 70% residential and
30% non-residential. In March of 2004, they used the
comparison of $131,000. To get to the absolute bottom of
this, no one is concerned about median, average or
anything. They are concerned what is the impact on them
personally. His recommendation to the Acting Town
Manager is not to talk medians or averages. We could
give them information based on our existing budget,
however, the bills go out around Christmas, before the
budget process starts.
Councilor Broxterman commented that people don’t like
comparisons if they don’t fit their argument. You have
to make a comparison to decide if this is intolerable,
you may have to choose another town and decide if that
municipality provides the services that Windsor does. He
feels that Windsor provides excellent services. He
pleaded with residents to check other towns and their
amenities. You will find that those people are just as
upset at their increases as we are. Some of those towns
are going to defer or delay those increases because they
are so high that their constituents will not put up with
it. They will have zero growth. The grass isn’t
necessarily greener on the other side. There are towns
who may have better senior services or better
educational services, but as a whole we have good
services. He doesn’t like to be told that he plotted to
slip this in and it’s not pleasant and it’s not going to
go away. Staff and Council will do their best to convey
this in a better fashion. He has been involved in the
process for fifteen years and still gets confused. If
there is a better way, they are open to it and he is
willing to listen.
Deputy Mayor Curtis appreciates Acting Town Manager
Souza’s explanation of the error. There are other towns
going through the same issues right now and are trying
to figure out what to do about it. Some condominiums in
Bloomfield will go up 100% next year. Deputy Mayor
Curtis asked if there is some way for us to shift the
burden from residential to commercial or industrial. Mr.
Kosofsky said that there was no way the town can to do
this under Connecticut statutes. The statutes are very
clear that all properties shall be assessed at 70% of
fair market value. Valuations in 2003 were based on
market values at that time. If a commercial or
industrial property is income producing, they must rely
more heavily on the income approach, otherwise they use
sales data according to state statutes.
Councilor Simon clarified that the 15% tax impact is
average. The 11% tax impact based on reval is the
correct median tax increase from the last reval to the
current reval. The budget impact was 4%. It isn’t town
spending that caused your tax increases to go as high as
they went, it is the increase in the value of your home
that caused this issue. The crux of this issue is that
people feel that they were given bad information. If the
Council had known 4-6 weeks before the budget what the
impact would be they would have made different decisions
on the budget. However, when they believed it would be
5.8% they didn’t make alternate decisions. Revaluation
will not change. People in the town have the right to a
benchmark figure as to what the impact will be, perhaps
a median tax impact vs. a median home value. We can’t
let this sort of thing happen again, we need to find out
why it happened.
Councilor Mulligan asked if any of the
commercial/industrial properties listed on Mr.
Rutkowski’s chart have taken advantage of the tax
abatement program. Mr. Kosofsky said that none of them
had. Acting Town Manager Souza added that there may be
one or two who had received infrastructure assistance.
Councilor Ellingwood asked if we have thought about
long term trends related to the industrial/commercial
property. He senses that there is a reverse trend to the
glory days of industrial growth in Windsor. Acting Town
Manager Souza responded that the economic development
within the region has changed, moving from industrial
and manufacturing basis to warehousing and logistics.
The TP&Z passed zoning restrictions along the Day Hill
Road corridor to encourage office building and
warehousing space. That is one of the reasons the tax
abatement policy was created.
Councilor Jepsen commented that on the day we passed
the budget, he asked the Town Manager about the
$138,000, questioning the $131,000 figure. Our budget
book has a 7.9% tax increase, where did that number come
from. The change in residential values comes out to 15%,
it is not the right way to do it, but it is closer than
the 5.8% or 7.9%. He thinks that this is more than a
mistake and it needs to be investigated.
Mayor Trinks does not feel it was intentional and
said that if there were any wrongdoings, the Town
Manager and/or his staff would be removed. He does not
to this day feel that there was misrepresentation, an
error perhaps. This is the way we have always looked at
these figures. Now we have it and what can we do about
it. We can make changes for next year. He thought and
hoped that commercial/industrial would also follow
residential property value increases, but it didn’t.
This wasn’t malicious. Unfortunately the burden shifted
onto residential. As a Council, we approved a position
in Economic Development to bring additional business to
the town. We are running out of development space in
town. There may be commercial development near
residential areas. We can’t have it both ways. From
January to June this year, our average home sale was
$209,000. Our housing values are up and so are our
taxes. You won’t find a cheaper community unless you
want to move to East Hartford or Plainville. Should we
have taken those numbers and followed up on them? Yes.
He has been on this Council longer than any other member
has and all through the years they followed the same
process. He apologizes for those whose taxes have gone
up well in excess of the amounts that they thought they
would.
Councilor Dean said that she would not have voted for
the budget had she known that those numbers would be
different. She herself, was told that she would have a
17% increase, and she was told that certain areas in
Windsor are in higher demand and have higher market
values. We haven’t seen mortgage rates this low in over
40 years. She doesn’t understand how the numbers turned
out like that. The residents were under the impression
that it was a 5.8% increase and they budgeted for that.
They are looking for an explanation.
Councilor Walker said there are still a lot of
questions that he has and this body depends on town
staff to put the numbers together. We have a Finance
Committee that meets and goes over the numbers to verify
and double check. He is not going to blame too much
because blaming doesn’t solve the problem. This body
needs to acknowledge that publicly there were errors and
that was done tonight. We need to communicate to all
residents the numbers. We need to put something simple
in writing. Accompany that with a plan of how we plan on
preventing this in the future. He asked when and how
soon do we communicate to the residents, they have a
right to know.
Councilor Jepsen can understand if it was a mistake.
To him, the single most important number that the
residents look at should not be a mistake, especially
more than one mistake. If we don’t do our due diligence
and track it down, we are not doing our job.
Moved by Deputy Mayor Curtis, seconded by Councilor
Jepsen to move Item 12. E. to this point in the agenda.
Motion Passed 9-0-0
- Approve appropriation to Archer Memorial A.M.E.
Church for Windsor Freedom Trail activlites
Approve appropriation to Archer Memorial A.M.E.
Church for Windsor Freedom Trail activities
Moved by Deputy Mayor Curtis, seconded by Councilor
Walker that $7,890 from the General Services, Community
Services Account, Arts and Culture Allocation, be
appropriated to the Archer Memorial A.M.E. Zion Church
to support Windsor Freedom Trail celebration activities.
Motion Passed 8-0-0 (see below for amended motion)
During the budget adoption process, the Town Council
reduced the proposed appropriation to the Archer
Memorial A.M.E. Zion Church for annual Freedom Trail
Celebrations by $7,890. These funds were placed in a
so-called Arts and Culture Allocation fund, with the
understanding that the celebration committee could
request an appropriation from the Town Council at a
later date.
The Archer Memorial A.M.E. Zion Church Freedom Trail
Committee is requesting an appropriation of $8,730 to
fund the 2004 Windsor Freedom Trail activities.
Specifically, the funds would be used to support the
annual Gospel Festival, which is planned for September
25th. The cost of producing the festival is
estimated to be $10,180.
The requested amount is in addition to the $4,110,
which was approved as part of the FY 2005 budget and is
used to fund other annual Freedom Trail activities in
town. The additional funds would need to be appropriated
out of the General Government, Community Services
Account, Arts and Culture Allocation fund. An allocation
of $41,690 was set aside. To date, the Town Council has
appropriated a total of $31,700 to Celebrate Windsor and
the Caribbean Cultural Showcase, leaving an available
balance of $9,990. This amount is not adequate to fund
both WIN-TV and Freedom Trail requests, which comes to a
total of $15,030.
Councilor Ellingwood asked about the change from
SummerWind to WHS. Mr. Alfred Narcisse, Chairman of the
Freedom Trail and member of the Connecticut Trail
Planning Committee, responded that they could not go
with SummerWind without a canvas so they switched it to
the high school and they plan on going back to
SummerWind once the canvas is replaced. Councilor
Ellingwood asked if costs went down or up from the
switch in venue. Mr. Narcisse said that the costs went
down. Councilor Ellingwood asked if cuts could be made
to the miscellaneous line if a reduction had to be made.
Mr. Narcisse said that "miscellaneous" covers security
and other costs.
Deputy Mayor Curtis said that the Council never saw
the original request of $12,840, they saw the $12,000
requested in the budget book. That is why the original
amount of $4,110 was adopted and the remaining was set
aside.
Councilor Mulligan has a problem with this procedure
because there is a budget process. We went through the
process and passed the budget and are now finding out
that it was not what was originally requested.
Councilor Ellingwood supports the budgeted amount of
$7,890.
Councilor Dean asked if the event could go on with
the decreased amount. Mr. Narcisse said that at this
late date, they would have to make it work rather than
risk the event not happening.
Amended by Councilor Ellingwood, seconded by
Councilor Jepsen that $7,890 from the General
Government, Community Services Account, Arts and Culture
Allocation fund, be appropriated to the Archer Memorial
A.M.E. Zion Church to support Windsor Freedom Trail
celebration activities.
Amendment Passed 6-2-0 (Mayor Trinks absent,
Councilor Walker and Deputy Mayor Curtis opposed)
-
Accept the deed of state-owned parcel on Deerfield
Road Moved by Councilor Broxterman, seconded by Councilor
Walker to adopt the attached resolution entitled,
"RESOLUTION ACCEPTING THE CONVEYANCE OF .12 ACRES OF LAND
FROM THE STATE OF CONNECTICUT".
The development of the town’s "Redevelopment Parcel"
located south of I-291 and east of Route 159, requires
assembly of four separate tracts of land. Mr. Jim Burke,
Economic Development Director, and Mr. Jim Hallisey,
Community Development Coordinator, explained the
discontinuance of a portion of Deerfield Road.
To complete the site assembly, the town must accept a
deed from the State for the conveyance parcel and
formally discontinue the use of a portion of Deerfield
Road. This will allow the entire site to be contained
within a continuous boundary and under one ownership.
Mr. Hallisey addressed the utility issue that was
brought up earlier. The proposed resolution specifically
calls for a provision of easements to existing
utilities.
Motion Passed 9-0-0
- Approve the discontinuance of a portion of
Deerfield Road
Moved by Councilor Broxterman, seconded by
Councilor Walker to adopt the attached resolution
entitled, "RESOLUTION TO DISCONTINUE A PORTION OF
DEERFIELD ROAD RIGHT OF WAY".
Motion Passed 9-0-0
- Approve waiving of first right of refusal for the
transfer of Fitch Court Apartments, 156 Bloomfield
Avenue
Moved by Councilor Jepsen, seconded by Councilor
Broxterman that the Town of Windsor waives its right of
first refusal on the sale of 156 Bloomfield Avenue
(Fitch Court Apartments) with regards to the proposed
Quit Claim deed from the Housing Authority of the Town
of Windsor to Fitch Court Apartments, Inc. provided that
the town retains a first right of refusal for future
sales of said property.
Acting Town Manager Souza gave a brief overview.
Fitch Court is located at 156 Bloomfield Avenue and has
been owned by the Town of Windsor since 1924, serving as
a school and recently as elderly housing. Fitch Court
was converted to a housing complex in 1985 when the town
entered into a 60-year lease with a private development
firm. The Connecticut Housing Finance Agency foreclosed
on the property in January 1999 due to the private
developer’s lack of financial performance. In the spring
of 2001, the Town Council and a Special Town Meeting
approved the transfer of the property to the Windsor
Housing Authority. Included in the Quit Claim deed was a
first right of refusal on any proposed sale of property
in favor of the town.
Fitch Court will continue to be used for senior
housing. The town will retain a first right of refusal
for future sales of the property.
Motion Passed 9-0-0
F. Approve appropriation to WIN-TVMoved by Councilor Simon, seconded by Councilor Dean
that $2,100 from the General Government, Community
Services Account, Arts and Culture Allocation fund, be
appropriated to WIN-TV.
Acting Town Manager Souza gave a brief overview.
During the budget adoption process, the Town Council
reduced the proposed appropriation of $15,000 to WIN-TV
by $6,300. These funds were placed in a so-called Arts
and Culture Allocation. The use of these funds would be
for annual operating costs. WIN-TV has also asked for a
$12,500 appropriation for the purchase of equipment.
WIN-TV is now requesting $6,300. This amount is in
addition to the $8,700, which was approved as part of
the FY 2005 Budget. The $8,700 is the same level of
funding as WIN-TV received in FY 2004. If the Town
Council approves additional financial support, it is
recommended that the funds be appropriated out of the
General Government, Community Services Account, Arts and
Culture Allocation fund.
An allocation of $41,690 was set aside in the above
account. To date, the Town Council has appropriated a
total of $31,700 to Celebrate Windsor and the Caribbean
Cultural Showcase, leaving an available balance of
$9,990. This amount is not adequate to fund both WIN-TV
and Freedom Trail requests, which comes to a total of
$15,030.
WIN-TV’s request for capital funding is not being
recommended as there is no identified funds available in
the FY 2005 Budget other than the General Fund
Undesignated Fund Balance.
Mayor Trinks is very reluctant to spend anything
above and beyond budgeted amounts.
Councilor Ellingwood supports the $2,100 that is
remaining in the fund.
Councilor Broxterman will not support this because
WIN-TV is not fundraising. In his opinion, they are
supported very strongly. The school board also provides
$15,000.
Motion Passed 7-2-0 (Mayor Trinks and Councilor
Broxterman opposed)
Moved by Councilor Jepsen, seconded by Councilor
Broxterman to extend the meeting by fifteen minutes.
Motion Passed 9-0-0
-
Resignations and Appointments
None.
Resignations and Appointments Minutes of Preceding Meetings
- Minutes of the July 6, 2004 Regular Town Council
Meeting
Moved by Councilor Broxterman, seconded by Councilor
Jepsen to accept the minutes of the July 6, 2004 Regular
Town Council Meeting. Corrections: Page 1 – Item 5.
Public Communications and Petitions, Mr. George
Yeramian’s comments should be: "He asks the Council now
to start a procedure to reroute the horrible dump
traffic down Knolls Road, directly off of Day Hill Road
through the woods to the dump road gate.
Motion Passed 9-0-0
- Public Communications and Petitions
Mr. Richard Rutkowski, 295 Kings Landing, suggested
that they consider hiring a professional statistician
during the upcoming budget process. He believes it will
be money well spent. He commended the Assessor, Steve
Kosofsky, for giving him the statistical information and
values he presented earlier. He was very sincere and
professional.
Mr. Bill Generous, 30 Karen Circle, appreciates
Acting Town Manager Souza’s elaboration and admission of
a mistake. Citizens did not come here tonight to cut the
budget, there was a disconnect with what they were told
and the actual tax increase. His e-mails explained
possible solutions as well as the facts. He proposed
scrapping the revaluation and keeping the current
budget, leading to a 4.1% increase and the reval could
be put off until 2006. Just because properties
appreciate substantially does not mean that the property
tax will go up substantially. Why wait for the market to
shift from residential to commercial/industrial.
Mr. Richard Rutkowski, 295 Kings Landing, applauded
the Council for adopting an annual revaluation so you
won’t see these big spikes. The problem he has with it
is doing it by a table top computer reval. There are
residents in town who make improvements without permits
in this town. A drive-by reval is also dangerous. If we
are going to do a reval every year, hire a competent
firm every year to do a sampling of these homes.
Mr. Edward Thomas, 192 Capen Street, said his faith
has been shaken tonight. It seems like there is a lack
of intelligence in how this process goes about. It is a
serious issue that deserves to be discussed and acted
upon immediately.
Moved by Councilor Jepsen, seconded by Councilor
Broxterman to extend the meeting by fifteen minutes.
Motion Passed 9-0-0
Moved by Councilor Jepsen, seconded by Councilor
Broxterman to enter into Executive Session at 11:15 p.m.
for the purpose of:
- Strategy and negotiations with respect to pending
claims and litigation
- Discussion of the appointment, employment,
performance, evaluation health or dismissal of a
public officer or employee
Motion Passed 9-0-0
- Executive Session
Present: Mayor Trinks, Deputy Mayor Curtis,
Councilor Broxterman, Councilor Ellingwood, Councilor
Dean, Councilor Jepsen, Councilor Mulligan, Councilor
Simon and Councilor Walker
Guests: Acting Town Manager Peter Souza, Town
Assessor Steve Kosofsky
Acting Town Manager Souza and Town Assessor
Kosofsky left Executive Session at 11:30 p.m.
Moved by Councilor Broxterman, seconded by
Councilor Jepsen to exit Executive Session and
reconvene the Regular Town Council meeting at 11:53
p.m.
Motion Passed 9-0-0
Moved by Councilor Jepsen, seconded by Councilor
Broxterman to extend the Regular Town Council meeting
until 11:55 p.m.
Motion Passed 9-0-0
Moved by Councilor Broxterman, seconded by
Councilor Mulligan that the terms of settlement
reached during the Town Council’s Executive Session in
the matter of Cadle Company versus the Town of Windsor
be accepted.
Motion Passed 7-0-0 (Deputy Mayor Curtis and
Councilor Walker out of room)
Moved by Councilor Jepsen, seconded by Councilor
Broxterman that the terms of the settlement reached
during the Town Council’s Executive Session in the
matter of SNET versus the Town of Windsor be accepted.
Motion Passed 9-0-0
- Adjournment
Moved by Councilor Jepsen, seconded by Councilor
Broxterman to adjourn the Regular Town Council Meeting
at 11:56 p.m.
Motion Passed 9-0-0
Respectfully submitted,
Kristin Countryman
Clerk of the Windsor Town Council
Cc: Town Clerk
Main Library
Wilson Branch
AN ORDINANCE APPROVING THE SALE OF
EAST STREET PROPERTY IN THE AMOUNT OF $130,000.00
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE TOWN OF WINDSOR:
Section 1. A contract for the sale of the land and
any improvements thereon on East Street, Windsor,
Connecticut between the First School Society of the Town
of Windsor and the Town of Windsor dated is hereby
approved.
Section 2. The Town Manager is authorized to make
such modifications as may be required from time to time
in the contract which does not substantially change the
terms thereof and to execute all closing documents and
expend such funds as may be required to effect the
closing of title and to enforce the contract.
Section 3. This Ordinance shall become effective ten
(10) days after publication in a newspaper having
circulation in the Town of Windsor after approval of a
Special Town Meeting.
APPROVED AS TO FORM:
___________________________________
Town Attorney
ATTEST:
___________________________________
Town Clerk
Distributed to Town Council: 7/16/04
Public Hearing Advertised: 7/23/04
Referred to Town Meeting: 8/02/04
Town Meeting Approval: 9/07/04
Publication Date: 8/23/04
Effective Date: 9/2/04
Schedule A
Deed Description – 126 East Street,
Windsor, CT
A certain piece or parcel of land together with any
improvements thereon located at 122/124T East Street,
Windsor, Connecticut and also shown as Lot 1 on a map
entitled "Proposed Subdivision Plan Prepared for
First School Society, Fuss & O'Neill, Inc.,
Consulting Engineers, date 6/7/04, Sheet 1 of 1",
to be recorded on the Land Records of the Town of
Windsor.
Beginning at a point on the easterly streetline of
East Street, being the same point as the south westerly
corner of property now or formerly of Eugene and Martha
Lehman, as described in Volume 470 Page 128 of
the Windsor Land Records, thence running N
68-53'-55" E a distance of 172.42 feet to a point,
thence N 68-26'20" E a distance of 149.79 feet to a
point, thence N 69-39'-28" E a distance of 253.11
feet to a point thence N 70-17'-52" E a distance of
444 feet more or less to the Farmington River thence in
a generally south easterly direction along the edge of
the water of the Farmington River to a point a distance
of 962 feet more or less to a point, thence S
58-27'-43" W a distance of 431 feet more or less to
a point, thence N 09-58'-23" E a distance of 70.78
feet to a point, thence N 24-28'-19" W a distance
of 699.85 feet to a point, thence S 75-01'20" W a
distance of 732.01 feet to a point, thence N
15-47'-43" W a distance of 85.01 to a point, thence
S 75-01'-20" W a distance of 150 to a point on the
easterly streetline of East Street, thence N 15-47'43 W
along said easterly streetline of East Street a distance
of 71.09 feet to the point and place of beginning.
The Town of Windsor reserves an easement for the
purpose of perpetual enjoyment of the riverfront for its
citizens in the area designated as the 100 year flood
plain on Flood Plain maps in the Town of Windsor. That
easement shall be from the river’s edge to the top of
the slope as shown on said maps. The Town of Windsor
reserves entry from the public road to said easement
area for use by pedestrian and vehicular access and for
construction and maintenance equipment.
RESOLUTION PROVIDING FOR THE
DISCONTINUATION THE RIGHT OF WAY OF A PORTION OF
DEERFIELD ROAD
WHEREAS, the Town of Windsor has identified the
land situated immediately east of Route 159 and
extending to Decker’s brook, and south of the I-291 on
ramp as appropriate for redevelopment; and
WHEREAS, said property is presently comprised of
various separately described parcels, including a
right-of way for the southerly end of Deerfield Road
which is no longer used as a travel way; and
WHEREAS, the Town Council find that is in the
public interest to assemble the various parcels into a
single parcel to render the site more desirable for
redevelopment; and
WHEREAS , the Town Council has the authority
to discontinue a town road under Section 13a-49 of the
Connecticut General Statutes and Section 3-6 of Windsor’s
Town Charter.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE TOWN COUNCIL OF
WINDSOR, CONNECTICUT:
Section 1. That the right-of-way of portion of
Deerfield Road as described on Schedule A (attached) is
hereby discontinued subject to the provision of
easements to existing utilities.
Section 2. That the Town Manager is hereby authorized
and directed to file a copy of this resolution in the
Records of the Windsor Town Clerk.
Passed, approved and adopted this 2nd day of August,
2004.
___________________________
Donald S. Trinks, Mayor
|
|
|